Reports from the Global Atheist Convention were not encouraging of respect, tolerance and the nurture of a healthy society.
In reading The Age article, Dawkins delivers the sermon they came to hear, I was struck by the
1. lack of scholarship, let alone grace, in the ‘Nazi Pope’ comment – Surely the scholar that Dawkins clearly is in science would have investigated and found out that all German youths at 14 years, which included the current Pope, were conscripted into Hitler Youth, the Nazi fascist cause at that time.
2.avoidance of serious conversation with the subject matter as for example when Dawkins says, ”It’s just surreal (that theologians believe in miracles) and completely gives the lie to the claim that the sophisticated theologians should look down on fundamentalist wingnuts. They are all the same.”
3. personal aggression – ‘playing the man and not the ball’. As in ABC’s Robyn Williams’ comment on Dawkins’ remark concerning Senator Fielding’s belief in creationism:
“I can give you a devastating argument against religion in two words,” Williams said in his introduction. “Senator Fielding. Richard Dawkins said his IQ is lower than an earthworm, but I think earthworms are useful.”
I also disagree with Senator Fielding on creationism but I pray to God that I would not belittle his person because of this difference of opinion.
4. gross over generalisations, “They are all the same.”
5. dismissive arrogance as above, “they (sophisticated theologians and fundamentalist wingnuts) are all the same.” Also Dawkins’ statement that Mary MacKillop’s canonisation by ”Pope Nazi” was ”pure Monty Python”. As much as many may have reserves about çanonisation, this mockery is arrogant in its dismissal and uncaring and disrespectful of other’s beliefs. Not the sort of society most of us want to live in. What lies behind such conduct? – surely not the building of a caring and compasionate society.
6. Why does a person who is a scholar in one field of study suspend their scholarly approach when in another field of study? Surely Dawkins’ unscholarly grand-standing will start to wear thin on even the most convinced atheist?
The Australian newspaper report on the conference, Celebrating life beyond belief, likewise teems with the atheist speakers’ simplicisms, ridicule, easy laughs and self-congratulation.
In the light of the above, I was intrigued by the thoughtful discernment in Why atheists’ ridicule won’t win friends and influence people.
Evaluating the convention depends on what one considers its purpose. If it was to validate hardline atheists to themselves and give them confidence, it was a triumph. If it was to take a mature look at how to advance the cause of secularism, politically and socially, the speakers should probably have spent less time ridiculing religion and more on positive and practical ideas.
. . . Also unworthy were ABC science presenter Robyn Williams offering “a devastating argument against religion in two words: Senator Fielding”; former Hillsong member Tanya Levin: “I’m finally getting to hang out with the adults”; and Rationalist Society president Ian Robinson, asking whether there were any believers in the audience. “OK, I’ll speak really slowly.” (Wild applause after each.)
What was missing was any sign of self-deprecation. Atheism will be a mature movement in Australia when atheists can laugh not just at the religious, but at themselves.
See also Atheist bus in Melbourne.
Leave a Reply